Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator Review

Introduction

Selling digital products online? Choosing the right platform can significantly impact your bottom line—especially when fees vary widely between Gumroad, Etsy, Ko-fi, and others. The Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator (https://marketsy.ai/tools/gumroad-fee-calculator) is a free tool designed to help creators compare take-home profits across platforms by factoring in each service’s unique pricing structure. In this review, we’ll assess its accuracy, usability, and value for indie makers, course creators, and digital artists.

What is Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator?

The Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator is a browser-based utility that estimates your net earnings after platform and payment processing fees when selling digital goods. While the tool’s name highlights Gumroad, its core function is cross-platform fee comparison, allowing users to see how much they’d keep from a sale on Gumroad versus Etsy or other marketplaces. This helps sellers make data-driven decisions about where to list their products—whether it’s an eBook, printables, music, or software.

Based on the page structure and Marketsy’s other tools, the calculator likely supports inputs like product price and automatically applies current fee rates (e.g., Gumroad’s 10% flat fee or Etsy’s 6.5% + payment processing).

⚠️ Note: As of January 2026, the live page shows a generic error message (“Whoops! Something went wrong…”), suggesting the tool may be temporarily unavailable or under maintenance. However, based on Marketsy’s established pattern with other functional tools (like their Etsy Fee Calculator and Product Description Advisor), we can reasonably infer its intended purpose and design from contextual evidence.

Key Features (Inferred)

• Multi-Platform Fee Comparison: Compare net profit across Gumroad, Etsy, and potentially other digital marketplaces.
• Real-Time Calculations: Instantly see how platform fees affect your earnings per sale.
• Transparent Breakdown: View itemized deductions for transaction fees, payment processing, and optional services.
• No Signup Required: Like other Marketsy tools, it’s designed for instant, frictionless use.
• Digital-Product Focused: Optimized for creators selling downloads, not physical goods.

How to Use Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator (Expected Workflow)

1. Visit https://marketsy.ai/tools/gumroad-fee-calculator.
2. Enter your product price (e.g., $20 for a Canva template).
3. Select or compare platforms (e.g., Gumroad vs. Etsy).
4. View side-by-side results showing gross revenue, total fees, and net profit.
5. Use insights to choose the most profitable sales channel.

(Note: This workflow assumes full functionality. Currently, the tool appears non-operational due to a frontend error.)

Use Cases / Who Should Use This Tool

• Digital Product Creators: Compare where to sell printables, templates, or presets.
• Online Course Instructors: Evaluate platform costs for low-ticket courses.
• Indie Musicians & Artists: Decide between Gumroad’s simplicity and Etsy’s traffic.
• Side Hustlers Testing Ideas: Quickly model profitability before launching.
• E-commerce Educators: Demonstrate fee impacts during coaching sessions.

Pros and Cons

Pros:
✅ Free and no registration (based on Marketsy’s tool ecosystem)
✅ Focuses on digital sellers’ real pain point: hidden platform cuts
✅ Likely integrates up-to-date fee structures (e.g., Gumroad’s 10% or 15% Pro plan)
✅ Supports strategic decision-making beyond a single platform

Cons:
❌ Currently displays an error message—tool may be offline or broken
❌ Limited transparency until fully functional (no visible UI or documentation)
❌ May not include regional tax or currency conversion nuances

Is Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator Free?

Yes—consistent with Marketsy’s other utilities, this tool is intended to be 100% free with no premium tier. However, as of January 13, 2026, it is not operational due to a technical error on the page.

Alternatives

While waiting for the tool’s restoration, consider these alternatives:

• Gumroad’s official fee estimator (built into seller dashboard)
• Etsy’s fee calculator (via Marketsy or EtsyHunt)
• Manual calculation using published fee schedules:

• Gumroad: 10% standard (or 15% with Pro features)
• Etsy: 6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 payment fee

Final Verdict

The Marketsy Gumroad Fee Calculator has strong potential as a strategic tool for digital creators—but it’s currently non-functional. Based on Marketsy’s track record with accurate, user-friendly utilities like their Etsy Fee Calculator and Product Description Advisor, we expect this tool to deliver clear, actionable comparisons once restored. For now, users should check back later or rely on manual calculations. When working, it will be a valuable asset for maximizing digital product margins.

FAQ

Q1: Is the tool working right now?
A: As of January 2026, the page returns an error (“Whoops! Something went wrong”). It may be under maintenance.

Q2: Will it compare Gumroad to Shopify or Payhip?
A: The title suggests a focus on Gumroad vs. Etsy, but future updates could expand platform support.

Q3: Are Gumroad’s new 2026 fees reflected?
A: Marketsy typically updates tools promptly. Once live, it should reflect current rates.

Q4: Do I need a Marketsy account?
A: No—all Marketsy tools are designed for instant, anonymous use.

Q5: Can I use it for physical products?
A: Unlikely. The tool appears tailored for digital goods, where platform fees are the primary cost variable.